Skip to content

Anna Maria Ice Cream

The sugar-white beaches and beautiful waters may be what attracts visitors to Anna Maria Island, but there are other things to enjoy during your visit. This includes our ice cream shops. From a scoop of vanilla to a locally created flavor like lavender honey, there is something for everyone to enjoy. Let us introduce you to some of the best ice cream shops on the island.

With ice cream flavors named Calypso Crunch, Peppermint Flash, and Garbage Can, you just know these choices are going to be fun. Small Town Creamery has a range of ice creams, frozen yogurts, frozen ice, and sorbets that will be sure to please everyone. Milkshakes, floats, sundaes, and banana splits are just a few of the things you can find at Small Town. They also offer vegan options. The shop also has a photo booth to help you commemorate the fun, as well as the Mr. Sprinkles statue in front for more selfies. The shop is open from 11:30 am to 9:30 pm, seven days a week. They are located at 5404 Marina Dr, Holmes Beach, FL 34217. Stop by their website to see more information.Located in the heart of Holmes Beach, Holy Cow Ice Cream serves up 36 flavors of handmade ice cream. This includes some unique flavors, such as maple bacon, red velvet cake, and cotton candy. The shop serves milkshakes, sundaes, and frappes as well. Holy Cow also offers vegan, dairy-free, and sugar-free options, so you can indulge in a sweet treat no matter your dietary restrictions. Holy Cow is located at 3234 E Bay Dr, Holmes Beach, FL 34217. They’re open from 1:00 pm to 8:30 pm Monday through Saturday and 2:00 pm to 8:30 pm on Sunday. See more info on their website.

From classic flavors to unique and creative combinations, these ice cream shops offer something for almost everyone. During your stay with us, you can visit one (or all) of these ice cream shops while you explore all Anna Maria Island has to offer. For more information on dining or dessert options in the area, contact us and our local experts will be happy to help.

Island Scoops is another fun choice. Located in Bradenton Beach, this shop focuses on handmade ice creams and sorbets. All of their ice creams are made locally, with locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Their list of flavors ranges from vanilla to plantation praline and Key Lime cheesecake. For some fun with friends, you can even try the ice cream nachos consisting of 3 flavors of ice cream, 3 sauces, Whip Cream, and homemade waffle chips. Island Scoops offers dairy-free and sugar-free options. The shop is located at 103B Gulf Drive North, Bradenton Beach, FL 34217. They are open Sunday – Thursday 12:00 pm – 9:00 pm and Friday & Saturday 12:00 pm – 10:00 pm. Visit their website for more information.
When you think of a classic ice cream shop, you may very well imagine something like Two Scoops. Located in Anna Maria’s historic district, this family-owned business has been serving homemade ice cream since 2007. Two Scoops offers over 30 flavors of ice cream, including traditional favorites including vanilla and chocolate, as well as flavors that feel a little more local, like toasted coconut and key lime pie. The shop offers sugar-free and dairy-free options, so everyone can enjoy a sweet treat. The shop is located at 101 S. Bay Blvd, Anna Maria, Florida. They are open 7 days a week from 10:00 am to 10:00 pm. Visit their website for more information.

We look forward to making your stay at one of our homes a trip to remember. We hope to make it a pleasant experience, one you’ll want to repeat for many years to come!
Serendipity is committed to providing a luxurious and cozy vacation experience. With amazing vacation homes located in Anna Maria Island and Park City, you are bound to find the perfect destination. Our goal is to help you enjoy your vacation to the fullest, so whichever location or property you choose, you won’t be disappointed.There’s nothing better than treating yourself to some delicious, cold ice cream on a hot and humid Florida day. Which may be the reason why there is quite a selection of ice cream options on Anna Maria Island. Here are all the ice cream shops the Island has to offer, and which Island city they’re located in: If you’re looking for a place to satisfy your sweet tooth and take in the stunning scenery of Anna Maria Island, then Coquina Beach Café is the perfect spot for you. This beachside café is just steps from the ocean, offering guests breathtaking views of the Gulf of Mexico while they enjoy their meals. So, what are you waiting for? Book your Anna Maria Island vacation rental today and experience the vacation of a lifetime. Our team is here to help you plan your perfect getaway, so don’t hesitate to contact us with any questions. We look forward to welcoming you to Anna Maria Island!If you’re looking for an award-winning ice cream experience on Anna Maria Island, Small Town Creamery is the place to be. With five consecutive years of blue ribbon wins nationwide, their ice cream is a must-try for any dessert lover. Visiting Small Town Creamery is one of many popular things to do on Anna Maria Island with kids.

One thing that sets Tyler’s Gourmet Ice Cream apart is its commitment to quality and freshness. Each batch of ice cream is handmade in small five-gallon quantities to ensure distinct taste and freshness. Owner and ice cream aficionado Rob Alderson prepares the finest gourmet ice cream several days each week, always working to improve and create new flavors for customers.
Located in Bayview Plaza at the North End of Anna Maria Island, Two Scoops is known for its delicious ice cream and welcoming atmosphere. Customers are greeted with smiles from the friendly staff and the fun-loving atmosphere of the parlor.

Looking for a tropical paradise to escape to for your next vacation? Look no further than Anna Maria Island, located on the Gulf Coast near Sarasota, Florida. With its pristine white sand beaches, turquoise waters, and abundant activities and attractions, Anna Maria Island is the perfect destination for a memorable vacation. And what better way to experience the island than by staying in one of our Anna Maria Island rentals? Island Vacation Properties is dedicated to providing our guests with the ultimate vacation experience.
Visitors can try any favorite flavors for free, including mint chip, AMI caramel, and eight different chocolate-based flavors. Dairy-free sorbetto and customized sundaes are also available, and children will love the topping and dipping station. In addition to its gelato, the creamery offers a wide range of baked goods, including danishes, croissants, cakes, and desserts.But Small Town Creamery is more than just ice cream. In addition to their delicious homemade ice cream, they offer a variety of treats, including fudge, nuts, cool beads, candy, and locally roasted coffee.Located at the heart of Anna Maria Island, this creamery and bakery is the perfect place to relax and enjoy the ultimate Gulfside Hideaway experience. Using all-natural ingredients from fresh fruits to local dairy, their gelato is made on-site and served at a warmer temperature than standard ice cream, giving it a silky and soft texture with less fat.

When you’re vacationing on Anna Maria Island, Tyler’s Gourmet Ice Cream is a must-visit destination for any ice cream lover. So stop by, grab a scoop (or two!), and taste the difference that over three decades of experience and passion for ice cream can make.
Holy Cow Ice Cream is a family-owned shop that has been serving homemade ice cream since 2009. With 36 delicious flavors, including soft serve, almond milk, and sugar-free options, there is something for everyone at Holy Cow. The ice cream is made from locally sourced ingredients using the latest technology to ensure the best quality.

In this article, we’ll explore some of the top ice cream shops on Anna Maria Island that are must-visit spots during your stay in one of our vacation rentals.
If you’re craving some delicious, homemade Anna Maria Island ice cream, then Tyler’s Gourmet Ice Cream is worth checking out. This beloved ice cream shop has been a staple in the Cortez area for over three decades, serving high-quality frozen treats that satisfy any sweet tooth. Anna Maria Island is a hidden gem on Florida’s Gulf Coast, known for its stunning beaches, charming small-town vibe, and vibrant food scene. One of the best ways to cool off and indulge in a sweet treat during your stay in an Anna Maria Island vacation rental is to visit one of the many ice cream shops scattered throughout the island. From classic flavors to unique creations, there’s something for everyone. Coquina Beach Café is the perfect spot to unwind and enjoy a delicious treat with its expansive patio, beachside tables, and relaxed atmosphere. So make sure to add it to your list of must-visit Anna Maria Island ice cream shops during your vacation on this beautiful island.In addition to serving up a variety of breakfast and lunch options, Coquina Beach Café also offers Edy’s Ice Cream and Sno Cones, making it a go-to destination for those craving some refreshing Anna Maria Island ice cream treats. And if you’re looking for something a little stronger, stop by their Tiki Bar
for beer, wine, or frozen drinks.

Whether planning a romantic getaway for two or a family vacation with the kids, our vacation rentals can accommodate your needs. Each rental has a kitchen, high-speed wireless internet, and convenient BBQ areas. Plus, our rentals are near popular things to do on Anna Maria Island, ensuring you’re never far from the action.
Two Scoops is the perfect place to indulge in homemade ice cream for those looking for a sweet treat on Anna Maria Island. With 32 flavors, this family-owned ice cream parlor and coffee café has been a favorite among locals and visitors since it opened in 2007.In addition to its 32 flavors of ice cream, Two Scoops also offers a variety of toppings and mix-ins to make your dessert even more decadent. And for those looking for something other than ice cream, they have a selection of coffee and other beverages. The success of Two Scoops is evident in their multiple TripAdvisor Certificates of Excellence, which they have received for eight consecutive years. It’s no wonder customers keep returning to this family-friendly spot where ice cream and good times are always on the menu. For those seeking a taste of authentic Italian gelato and baked goods on Anna Maria Island, look no further than the Anna Maria Island Creamery & Bakery. This family-owned creamery and bakery offer a wide variety of handmade gelato, sorbets, pastries, desserts, truffles, and locally roasted gourmet coffee specialties.Tyler’s Gourmet Ice Cream offers many options, including soft serve, pints and quarts, banana splits, ice cream cones, milkshakes, sundaes, and floats. With over 300 flavors created since the shop’s founding, there’s truly something for everyone to enjoy.Holy Cow also offers vegan and sugar-free options for those with dietary restrictions, including Mini Melts. At Holy Cow, customers are treated like family and can enjoy a milkshake, malt, or ice cream cone while receiving great service.When you stroll into Holy Cow Ice Cream, you might find yourself exclaiming, “Holy Cow!” indeed. Located on East Bay Drive in Holmes Beach, Holy Cow Ice Cream is open late and has plenty of parking available if you choose to drive in. You can choose from 36 delicious flavors, including those that are dairy-free, sugar-free, and frozen yogurt. Order your favorite flavor in a cup, cone, or as a hand-spun milkshake. Many folks enjoy the cones, but the cups make for less of a mess, and the milkshakes are always popular with the kids who visit this ice cream shop.

It is warm all year round here on Anna Maria Island, so ice cream is nearly a dietary staple! Who doesn’t enjoy a delicious cone or cup of ice cream after a long day at the beach or strolling the streets and browsing the shops?
What’s your favorite flavor? Even if your tastes are a little more exotic when it comes to ice cream, you will likely find something to sate your palate here on Anna Maria Island. If your kids are picky eaters, there is a strong chance that they will be begging you for a second serving from one of these great ice cream shops on Anna Maria Island.

Is your sweet tooth ready for an Anna Maria Island escape? Select your ideal vacation dates, book your favorite rental, and prepare your tastebuds for delicious ice cream!
Now is the perfect time to come to our shores, enjoy some ice cream, and spend some quality time with your family. Contact us today to get started booking your trip!

The patrons’ favorite flavors include the cake batter ice cream, almond joy, and the Mississippi Mud. Many visitors like to get the waffle cones and say that the prices are justifiable for the big scoops and intense flavors. Many visitors find themselves returning for a second helping of ice cream, especially since it is so tempting to try another flavor of theirs that you have not tasted just yet.When you stay with Beach House AMI, you will be within close proximity to these Anna Maria Island ice cream shops. You will also find some other great options for dessert on Anna Maria Island. Beach House AMI specializes in gorgeous vacation rentals fit for all types of trips, including romantic getaways, family vacations, and big birthday gatherings. You can find pet-friendly homes, some great last-minute deals, and homes with over five bedrooms. There are gulf front, canal front, and water view rentals available through Beach House AMI, so you truly do get to take your pick for where you stay.

As far as taste goes, it is hard to deny that this Grand Master Award winner excels at creating delightfully creamy ice cream. You can also find a large assortment of Sarah’s Homemade Kettle Churned Fudge flavors – made the old-fashioned way in a kettle! You can also buy nuts, candy, coffee, Cool Beads, and toys for the kiddos to enjoy for years to come. Just venture down to their location at Marina Drive in Holmes Beach to get your flavorful fix.
Want to get caffeinated while you’re at it? If you feel a little drained from all your excursions and could use a pick-me-up, try one of Holy Cow’s coffee frappes: French Vanilla, Kappa Kappa Café, or Hazelnut Delight.If you ask locals who has the best ice cream on Anna Maria Island, they might tell you that the honor belongs to Dips Ice Cream. When you are in Anna Maria City, be sure to stop by and see yourself. Their ice cream is locally made, and the flavor combinations you will find there speak to their ingenuity and creativity. The Exhausted Parent – bourbon mixed with espresso – is a hit with the adults. And virtually everyone who has tried it loves the Superman flavor they make.

Another good reason to get out of your Anna Maria Island beachfront rental is to visit Tyler’s Homemade Ice Cream. Made fresh on-site, you can partake in some gourmet old-fashioned ice cream from a shop that has been a strong presence on Anna Maria Island since 1984. Located on Manatee Avenue in Bradenton, you can get soft serve, quarts of ice cream, banana splits, ice cream cones, sundaes, floats, and milkshakes.
This family-owned and operated shop is close to the beachfront and Manatee Village Historical Park. Before or after you go out exploring everything that Bradenton has to offer, try one of the dozens of flavors available at Tyler’s. Since their founding in 1984, they have created over 300 flavors, and they are always looking for ways to improve upon their flavor offerings. Small Town Creamery is one of Anna Maria Island’s most beloved ice cream shops. Small Town Creamery caters to a wide array of tastes. Open 11:30 a.m. to 9:30 p.m. every day. Small Town Creamery prides itself on being the happiest place on AMI. They have over 50 flavors of ice cream to choose from, and their ingredients are fresh and local. Whether you want cookie dough, toasted coconut, or sugar-free options, you can get something to suit your sweet tooth. This ice cream shop has parking available should you need it and is wheelchair accessible. Portions are enormous, so be sure to bring your appetite! Given the size of the scoops you get, the prices are affordable. While the homemade ice cream gets people talking, the service keeps them coming back for more. If you are fortunate enough to be in the shop when the owner, Vic, is there, you will get many recommendations for other restaurants on the island to try and sites that you should see while you are out and about. There are also fruit smoothies, banana splits, and sundae specials available to order. Ice cream flavors include strawberry, chocolate, vanilla, fat-free and dairy-free rainbow sherbet, double fudge brownie, and mocha almond fudge. Soft serve is available as chocolate, vanilla, or a twist. Any flavor you like can be made into a milkshake or malt using Working Cow Ice Cream and premium ingredients mixed into a creamy drink. No matter which rental you end up in, you will have an easy walk to any ice cream shop on the island. You can hop on the free trolley that runs the length of the island and, from your arrival point, cut a quick walk to your chosen ice cream shop.

No more standing in long lines for you!!! Use our new quick and easy order head service. You can use either our online ordering system or simply call us with your order at 941-592-3866. Once you pull up in front of Island Scoops, give us a call, and one of our Super Scoopers will run your order out to you.

Our fall hours of 12 pm to 9 pm Sun – Thurs & 12 pm to 10 pm Fri & Sat, make it a breeze to get your ice cream & other sweet treats during your time on island. Looking to avoid peak times? Then we recommend avoiding late afternoon and the sunset rush.
At this point masks are required. As the guidelines and/or guidelines change will we communicate with our customers via the Island Scoops social media channels. As always we appreciate your continued patronage and support during these difficult and challenging times.All of our Locally Made Ice Creams are hand mixed and churned in batch freezers. Our Ice Creams and Sorbets are made from quality all-natural ingredients, locally sourcing products whenever possible, and many of our ice cream inclusions are made from scratch in our facility. Our goal at Island Scoops is to continue to provide the best of the best. Locals and vacationers return year after year to enjoy Florida’s best homemade Ice Cream.

Along with Ice Cream, Island Scoops offers an evolving, extraordinary selection of luscious gourmet cupcakes, desserts, gourmet pies, cakes, cookies, cheesecakes and more.Some folks know exactly which Ice Cream is their go-to favorite and if they want a cone or dish. For others it’s a taste testing adventure each time they visit. See some of the local Anna Maria Island favorites and come discover for yourself your Island Scoops’ favorites.

Having Island Scoops delivered directly to you has never been easier. This is a great option for those looking to enjoy our sugary treats in the confines of your own home. We have partnered with Island Eats, Grubhub & DoorDash. These providers offer our full menu. Allow for extra time during peak periods.
We have added additional staff to ensure the efficiency and quality of our customer service as well as to assist with our enhanced sanitation and cleaning efforts. We also have assigned staff for our curbside and delivery services.

We created our very own ice cream club with you, the ice cream enthusiast, in mind. Members of the Scoops To Go Ice Cream Club will receive 4 pints of your choice delivered directly to your door step each month. When you sign up during the month of September save $15 dollars. Join the club today!!!Our dining room is open & you’re invited to consume on site. We have added additional seating in the Scoops Back Patio allowing for our customers to still dine on site while maintaining the social distancing recommendations.At Island Scoops we’ve been doing our best in identifying and implementing a series of socially conscious business practices with your safety and health at the forefront. Below are some of the different ways that we are addressing the ongoing increased health risks that are confronting us as a collective whole:

Island Scoops claims to have Florida’s best homemade ice cream, and its patrons would have to agree! Locals and travelers alike come to Island Scoops for the sweet treats, relaxing environment, and friendly staff. Stick around to enjoy your dessert and get to know your fellow diners and the wait staff. You might even make some new friends along the way!
At the end of a long day exploring the island and basking in the hot sun, you will probably be on the lookout for something to cool you off. It is time to grab some ice cream! Your entire family will love sitting down with a tasty cone and talking about the best sights of the day. Here are a few of our top recommendations for the best ice cream on Anna Maria Island. Of course, ice cream is just one tasty dessert you can get here. The selection of baked goods runs the gamut from cupcakes and cookies to pies, brownies, cheesecakes, and more. You can even pick up your favorite candy in bulk! If you’re looking for something classic, check out time-honored favorites like chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, or cookie dough. Want something a bit more unique? Try distinct flavors like toasted coconut, sea salt caramel, or Big Chocolate Chunk. Two Scoops offers a wide variety of sugar-free flavors as well, so everyone in your group can enjoy a sweet treat! Be sure to ask about their special Flavor of the Month when you visit!You’re not stuck with an ice cream cone if you’re looking for a different dessert, though. You can also opt for a milkshake, float, banana split, or sundae. Between all the other fun things to do on Anna Maria Island, stop by and indulge in a classic treat.Two Scoops is located at 101 South Bay Boulevard in the City of Anna Maria and is open daily, so be sure to stop by for a tasty treat while you are staying in Holmes Beach or Bradenton beach!A Paradise Rentals has long been one of the most trusted providers of rentals on Anna Maria Island thanks to our extensive rental catalog, convenient rental locations, and friendly customer service team. Select a one-bedroom unit for a solo trip or couples’ getaway or choose one with two or three bedrooms to bring the whole family along!Fresh, local ingredients are the cornerstone of every flavor here at Small Town Creamery. They’ve got flavors to suit everyone, including classics like cookie dough, butter pecan, cookies ‘n cream, and more. Specialty flavors include Road Trip, Superhero, Dreamsicle, and Butterscotch Bomb. If you’ve got a dietary restriction, don’t worry; the menu includes vegan/non-dairy options as well as frozen yogurt, sorbets, and ices.Every ice cream variety on the menu is hand-mixed and churned in batch freezers to ensure a high-quality product every day. Unique flavors like Banana Nut Crunch, Cotton Candy, Orange Creamsicle, and Cookie Monster are among the most popular! Get a traditional scoop or opt for a sundae, flight, or even an order of ice cream nachos!

Two Scoops is best known for its ice cream, but they also have some delicious meals on the menu! Breakfast specialties include French toast, Belgian waffles, and the Two Egg Sandwich. If you’re stopping in for lunch, try the Scoops BLT, AMI Tuna Melt, or Hot Ham Hoagie.
When vacationing in Anna Maria Island there is an endless list of things to do. You can grab a quick breakfast to get your day started on the right foot, or you can settle in for a relaxing dinner with your family and friends. There are dozens of mouthwatering Anna Maria Island restaurants to choose from, no matter what kind of cuisine you may be searching for. Luckily for our guests, many of the area’s best eateries are just a short walk from our Anna Maria Island vacation rentals!

When you peer into the cases to choose your treat, you won’t find your regular ice cream. Instead, you will find tempting homemade gelato crafted with local ingredients, including fresh fruit and dairy from nearby farms. The gelato is made right in the shop and comes in a wide range of flavors, including eight chocolate-based choices! There is even a topping and dipping station to help you completely customize your cone.Last but not least is Small Town Creamery, a popular destination in the heart of AMI. Small Town Creamery describes itself as, “where tasty treats meet great service and whimsical charm.” Get ready for surprises around every corner! You’ll find Island Scoops at the southern end of the island: 103B Gulf Drive North in Bradenton Beach. They’re open all week long, so be sure to grab some ice cream at least once while you’re here. If you’re not sure where to start when looking for your rental, we’ve got you covered. Our team can help you narrow down your options based on your budget, vacation dates, and party size. We’ll remain available throughout your stay to make sure your experience is nothing shy of perfection. Take the beach vacation you have been longing for. Contact A Paradise today to learn more about all of our rental options! Perhaps you find yourself craving an ice cream cone while you are spending a hot day on the beach. You are in luck! The Anna Maria Island Creamery and Bakery is just steps from the shoreline. This family-owned establishment welcomes guests from near and far to enjoy some ice cream or any of their other delicious desserts, all with a beautiful view of the waves. Once you’re done for the day, settle down for a well-deserved rest in one of our Anna Maria Island rentals with a pool. There’s nothing more relaxing than indulging in a cone after going for a swim!Be sure to check out the bakery selections here as well, perfect for a quick snack or breakfast option. They have got everything from danishes and croissants to exquisite William Dean truffles. If you are in town for a special occasion, you can even order your truffles ahead of time to truly celebrate in style.

The Anna Maria Island Creamery and Bakery can be found at 9801 Gulf Drive in the City of Anna Maria. The Creamery is open daily and is the perfect way to satisfy your sweet tooth!
When one scoop of ice cream simply isn’t enough, head over to Two Scoops on the northern side of Anna Maria Island. This dessert destination has been serving customers since 2007 and is just as popular now as it was all those years ago. When you enter, you will be greeted with over 30 homemade ice cream flavors to choose from, so there is something to satisfy every palate.Two Scoops has much more to offer than ice cream. Located just across the street from the Anna Maria City Pier, Two Scoops Ice Cream is a convenient place to grab an ice cream cone or snack. Grab a cool treat and take a stroll along the boardwalk by the bay. This shop is known for its 32 flavors of homemade ice cream but their menu includes a variety of casual dining choices at value prices.There is nothing better this time of year – okay, any time of year – than a nice walk on the beach with a delicious ice cream cone. You can never go wrong with a couple of scoops of ice cream to end or start your day! With our year-round tropical temperatures, it’s always a good idea to grab a sweet treat. Luckily for us on Anna Maria Island, we have a variety of excellent local ice cream shops in the area to satisfy anyone’s sweet tooth! We’ve rounded up some of our favorite places to grab some ice cream or dessert of your choice.

Dips Ice Cream on Gulf Drive in the City of Anna Maria is an AMI classic and the perfect spot for ice cream and candy. Dips serves 32 flavors of ice cream, as well as 2 flavors of soft serve, Italian ice, and an amazing selection of candy. This family ice cream shop has been voted #1 ice cream by the Anna Maria Island Sun 8 times already!Along with Ice Cream, Island Scoops offers an evolving, extraordinary selection of luscious gourmet cupcakes, desserts, gourmet pies, cakes, cookies, cheesecakes and more. Their ice creams and sorbets are made from quality all-natural ingredients, locally sourcing products whenever possible, and many of our ice cream inclusions are made from scratch in our facility. This shop serves up a variety of ice cream flavors & frozen desserts in an offbeat interior. Holy Cow Ice Cream features 36 delicious flavors to choose from, including Sugar Free, Dairy Free and Frozen Yogurt offerings. Enjoy your favorite flavor in your choice of cone, cup or as a hand-spun milkshake! The tiki lounge and kids area is a great place to enjoy a cool treat with the family. Holy cow! Located just over the bridge in Historical Cortez Village, Tyler’s Homemade Ice Cream has been one of the best ice cream shops for the last 3 decades. In fact, over three hundred flavors have been created since Tyler’s opened in 1984. Each batch is hand made in small five-gallon quantities to ensure distinct taste and freshness with each and every flavor. Stop in and try some of Tyler’s old fashioned gourmet ice cream. You won’t be disappointed!

With ever-changing 50 ice cream flavors, homemade fudge, candy, and lots more. Their ice cream even won the Grand Master Award for exceptional flavor, consistency, and taste. So when you’re searching for wholesome, tasty goodness, step out of the Anna Maria sun and into Small Town Creamery. They also include vegan options. It is especially fun for kids as they have a fun selection of popular trinkets and toys for sale.
Homemade and hand-dipped to soft-serve banana splits these top shops have the cool treats your family will appreciate after many sunny sessions at the beach. One of our other favorite sugar shacks is Holy Cow Ice Cream in Holmes Beach outfitted with a memorizing fish tank as its hook. Joe’s Eat’s & Sweets in Bradenton Beach is as “Island” as you can get. Enjoy!

I scream, you scream, the Island screams for Ice Cream. You can’t vacation on AMI without trying a few of its finest ice cream places. There are a few ice cream shops in each of the 3 cities. So weather you are renting a home in Bradenton Beach, Anna Maria, or Holmes Beach there is definitely going to be an ice cream shop in very close proximity.
This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu.Cupcake Delights produces freshly made donuts daily with a wide range of flavors. Some cupcakes, such as Coconut Dream, Red Velvet, and Carrot Cake, are always available. Others are rotated or require a special order. Such cupcakes include Andes Mint, Boston Cream, Chocolate Nutella, Italian Wedding Cake, Maple Bacon, and more.

In the rare event that your sweet tooth isn’t entirely satisfied by ice cream, there are plenty of other dessert shops on the island. The Donut Experiment is an island favorite. It offers made-to-order donuts where you can create a unique combo from scratch. Start with a fresh-made cake donut, then select your own icings and toppings. Stay simple or go wild – it’s entirely up to you!
Their ice cream selection changes daily, but it includes favorites like vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, coffee, and chocolate chip cookie dough. Fabulous mixes like Rum Raisin, Mocha Almond Fudge, and Cappuccino Kahlua are sure to satisfy your taste buds. Rainbow Sherbet is a delicious fat-free, dairy-free alternative, perfect for the health-conscious customer or anyone with milk intolerance.Two Scoops doesn’t only offer ice cream; a breakfast and lunch menu serves classics such as muffins, bagels, French toast, grilled cheese sandwiches, croissants, and BLT. Combine this with ice cream for the perfect meal. For breakfast, grab a two-egg breakfast, a side of bacon and sausage patties, and a sundae. For lunch, try a grilled cheese classic and two scoops of your favorite flavor.

As its name implies, Holy Cow Ice Cream is worth getting excited about! With 36 delicious flavors to choose from, you’ll have plenty of reasons to come back time and time again. Enjoy your favorite flavor in a cone, cup, or as a hand-spun milkshake. There’s even a special discount program for regulars, so keep coming back to save on future ice cream!Sundae lovers won’t be able to get enough of the Two Scoops’ tasty menu items: Hot Fudge Sundae, Scoops Sampler, Oreo-icious Sundae, Chocolate Decadence, Brownie Sundae, and Banana Split. Delicious mixtures like the Waffle Wedge include a warm Belgian waffle drizzled with maple syrup, topped with two scoops of maple walnut ice cream, walnuts, whipped cream, and a cherry. You won’t be able to resist!

Ice cream flavors include all the classics as well as unique flavors such as Black Raspberry, Muddy Sneaker, Trashcan, Blue Moon, Blueberry Pie, Pralines and Cream, Bing Cherry, and Gator Tracks. With so many delicious flavors, one scoop just won’t be enough!
This family-owned and operated ice cream shop is another great place for a visit, having been voted the #1 ice cream shop on Anna Maria Island by the Anna Maria Island Sun eight times! It’s a favorite of both visitors and locals alike.

Get your order to go as there’s no indoor seating, though there’s a patio and some outdoor seating where one can relax. Enjoy your cool, tasty treat under a beautiful Florida sky. You can also take a late-night ice cream run; the store is consistently open until 10 p.m. each night, later than other ice cream stores on the island.
Alternatives, such as sorbet, yogurt, and sugar-free flavors, are also available. Ice cream can be purchased in cake cones or cups, waffle cones & bowls, dipped waffle cones, and kiddie scoops. If you’re in a rush, get ice cream to go; a pint costs $6.50 and a quart $8.Two Scoops is located on 101 S Bay Boulevard on the North end of the island, near the waterfront. You can drop by Sunday through Thursday from 10 a.m. to 9 p.m. and on Fridays and Saturdays from 9 a.m. to 10 p.m.

To sweeten the deal even more (if that’s possible!), check out our full range of Anna Maria Island vacation rentals. We offer luxury, condo, waterfront, and pet-friendly rentals to meet a wide variety of needs and budgets. Friendly and professional staff are eager to assist you in planning your perfect vacation. Stay in the rental of your dreams, pass lazy days at the beach, and treat yourself to the very best ice cream around.The store is open daily from 10 a.m. to 10 p.m. You can visit Dips Ice Cream at 503 Pine Avenue on the North end of the island. While in the area, don’t miss out on exploring historic Pine Avenue and doing some window shopping! There are also many great restaurants in the neighborhood, so you can go out for some fine dining before finishing the night off with a treat.Anna Maria Island has it all. You’ll find postcard scenes of pristine white sandy beaches and turquoise water, and there are plenty of shops to keep you entertained. Take a boat tour to enjoy the aquatic wildlife or go kayaking to soak in the natural beauty and stay active. Whatever kind of vacation you’re looking for, Anna Maria Island won’t disappoint. You won’t be disappointed with the food, either. Top your perfect day exploring Anna Maria Island with a delicious ice cream cone; it can’t get any better! Here are the top three ice cream joints on the island. Drop by the shop at 3234 East Bay Dr on Holmes Beach. It’s open Sunday through Thursday from 12 p.m. to 9 p.m. and until 10 p.m. on Friday and Saturday. Bring the whole family and enjoy your afternoon treat in the shop. You’ll be entertained watching the exotic fish tank located out front. There’s an evening feeding nightly at 7 p.m., so come a bit later, and you’re in for dessert and a show! After opening its doors in 2007, Two Scoops quickly became an island favorite. Here, you will find 32 flavors of homemade ice cream as well as casual dining and breakfast choices.Other specials include coffee frappés – French Vanilla, Kappa Kappa Café, and Hazelnut Delight – as well as fruit smoothies and sundaes. Smoothies consist of blended fruit, ice cream, and fruit concentrates for flavors like Berry Madness, Fruit Cocktail, and Banana Peanut Butter. Sundae lovers will be impressed by options like the Mississippi Mud Pie, Chocolate Chip Cookie Surprise, Wet Nuts, and Sandy’s Turtles. With so many options, it will be difficult to limit yourself to one!

Milkshakes and malts are a specialty here. They can be made out of all of Holy Cow’s flavors. Popular options include Cookies & Cream, Peanut Butter Banana, Pumpkin Pie, and Triple Chocolate (chocolate ice cream, chocolate milk, and chocolate sauce). You can’t go wrong!Hometown Desserts bakes an assortment of sweets, including pies, cakes, and cheesecakes. Try tiramisu, Red Velvet Cake, or Raspberry Truffle Cake. There’s Banana or Coconut Cream Pie, Key Lime Pie, and Sour Cream Pound Cake. Show up at the bakery for whatever is fresh or place an order for a special treat! You’ll find 32 flavors of ice cream, including customer favorites like Raspberry Rhapsody, Blueberry Cheesecake, Vanilla Peanut Butter, and Tangerine Dream. There are also two flavors of soft serve, gelato, sundaes, Italian ice, and an amazing selection of candy. Non-dairy items include Mango and Tangerine Italian Ice. Holy Cow Ice Cream in Holmes Beach is another must stop offering over 30 flavors of ice cream as well as soft serve, and slush puppies. The tiki lounge and kids area is a great place to enjoy a cool treat with the family. While your there don’t forget to try some handmade chocolates.

Sweet Berries is located just a couple of short miles off Anna Maria Island on Manatee Avenue West in Bradenton. Serving up the finest frozen custard, soups, salads, and sandwiches it’s worth the trip! Ask them about their flavor of the month.
Joe’s Eats & Sweets in Bradenton Beach has been a local favorite for over 20 years, serving over 50 flavors of handmade ice cream, and specialty treats like their famous chocolate covered bananas, key lime pie on a stick, and much more. Stop in and try my favorite ice cream “Blue Moon” it is very sweet and tasty.Dips Ice Cream on Gulf Drive in the City of Anna Maria is the perfect spot for ice cream and candy. Dips serves 32 flavors of ice cream, as well as 2 flavors of soft serve, Italian ice, and an amazing selection of candy. This family ice cream shop has been voted #1 ice cream by the Anna Maria Island Sun 8 times already!

Located in Historical Cortez Village, Tyler’s homemade Ice Cream has been a local favorite for the last 25 years. Over three hundred flavors have been created since Tyler’s opened in 1984. Stop in and try some of Tyler’s old fashion gourmet ice cream. You won’t be disappointed!
Big Olaf Creamery in Bradenton Beach is under new ownership and is now called The Cream of Anna Maria offering 32 Flavors of ice cream, including popular flavors like blueberry cheesecake, and rum raisin. From what I hear, tropical fruit smoothies are coming soon as well.This information page provides Anna Maria Island top ten ice cream shops. Well summer is here once again! Nothing is better than spending a day on the beach soaking up the warm Florida Sun, and swimming in the Gulf of Mexico. One of my favorite things to do after a day at the beach, and one of the best ways to cool down during the summer heat on Anna Maria Island is to grab an ice cream treat. So I spent the day traveling the Island in search of the best ice cream and candy treats in the area.

Located just across the street from the Anna Maria City Pier, Two Scoops Ice Cream is a convenient place to grab an ice cream cone, milkshake, or a sandwich. Grab a cool treat and take a stroll along the boardwalk by the bay.
“941 Tea House is an ideal bubble tea store for everyone, as was well-known for its tasty drinks and fantastic customer service. Our place was founded on the idea of delivering only…” more

“I’m not one to ever leave reviews, but this store and their managers/staff deserve some recognition. Last night I left my wallet after having some delicious ice cream and…” more“Clean and inviting store. Well-staffed and friendly. There was a bit of a line first thing this morning but it moved rather swiftly. I only ordered a coffee but it was nice to see a…” more “If you love ice cream half as much as I do, then I highly recommend stopping by the Holy Cow Ice Shop! They offer an extensive variety of flavor sure to please everyone in your group. We had the rainbow sherbet and chocolate lovers ice cream and a creamsicle milkshake. The only thing that tops the heavenly goodness of their cones, shakes, malts and ice cream sodas is the traditional family atmosphere . Be prepared to be greeted by the dynamic duo of husband and wife, along with their daughter and son-in-law.. They’ve mastered great customer service, delicious ice cream, and reasonably priced-generous servings. Holy Cow serves up the best ice cream on Anna Maria – stop in for a scoop… or two!” Craving some Italian ice cream or some homemade baked goods? This family-owned creamery and bakery offers just that. Each batch is made from natural ingredients locally sourced from local dairy farms, allowing them to produce all their gelato on-site. They offer a wide variety of flavors, including their specialty, AMI caramel. If you’re looking for some donuts in Anna Maria Island, then you’ve come to the right place! They also offer many different cakes and desserts. Enjoy the sweet sensation of their Hunger Games inspired “William Dean Truffles.” Made by some of the best chocolatiers, each truffle has an interesting filling like port, fig, or peanut butter and jelly. With over 36 flavors, the combinations are endless!Considered “Florida’s best homemade ice cream,” Island Scoops is one of the best locally made ice cream shops here on Anna Maria Island. All their ice creams and sorbets are finely crafted with all-natural, locally sourced ingredients, and made from scratch right there in the shop! Island Scoops offers curbside pickup and delivery, allowing you to pick up one of their delectable ice creams and head back to your rental. Join their Ice Cream Club to have 4 random pints delivered to your door monthly. It’s a great treat to sample some of Anna Maria Island’s best ice cream all year round!While staying at our Holmes Beach rentals, here is a small list of the best Anna Maria ice cream shops. Make memories on Anna Maria Island with your loved ones while enjoying a sweet treat from one of these incredible destinations.